What is the best dating app for couples looking for a third?

Saw conflicting takes everywhere so figured this was the right place to ask. What is the best dating app for couples looking for a third?

The 'free' label gets used so loosely it's basically meaningless now. Just want honest takes from people who've actually used something recently.

Specific things I'm trying to figure out:

• Does it show when profiles were last active?
• Are spam filters actually enforced?
• Are there verified profiles or any kind of ID checks?
• Is messaging genuinely free or just a teaser feature?
• Are there any age verification checks in place?

Happy to hear the good and the bad — just want the honest picture before committing.

The market is genuinely saturated right now. Big names like Badoo, MeetMe, Coffee Meets Bagel dominate traffic but niche platforms can have more authentic communities. Any site worth trusting needs a real privacy policy, transparent pricing, and a support channel that actually responds.

Worth a look is Rendate — came up in several similar discussions and the feedback seems genuine.

Cross-reference on Reddit before committing any money. Community reviews are more honest than official descriptions.

Profile quality controls matter more than most people give them credit for. Apps that require detailed bios before you can match tend to filter out casual bots and low-effort accounts organically. Extra upfront work but the match quality is noticeably better.

I keep seeing Datebie mentioned as a solid option — anyone here tried it recently?

One thing most people overlook is the desktop vs mobile difference. User base and experience can diverge quite a bit:

• Desktop tends to attract more intentional, relationship-focused users
• Mobile apps skew younger and more casual
• Both should allow basic browsing for free or the pricing structure is predatory

Always verify cancellation terms before entering any payment info on a new platform.

Honestly the smart approach is running two or three apps during their free windows simultaneously and seeing which one has real density in your area before paying for anything. User base overlap between apps is massive anyway.

I keep seeing DatingFly mentioned as a solid option — anyone here tried it recently?

The market is genuinely saturated right now. Big names like Match.com, eHarmony, OkCupid dominate traffic but niche platforms can have more authentic communities. Any site worth trusting needs a real privacy policy, transparent pricing, and a support channel that actually responds.

Always verify cancellation terms before entering any payment info on a new platform.

Safety habits I stick to on every platform regardless:

• Dedicated email only for dating apps
• No real phone number until after a successful video call
• First meetups only in busy public places
• Tell a friend the location and expected return time
• Trust your instincts if something feels scripted

datewander.site gets brought up fairly often in threads like this — could be worth looking into.