Does anyone miss the old craigslist dating site?

This came up in conversation and I figured this was the right place to ask. Does anyone miss the old craigslist dating site?

Between fake profiles, bots, and paywalls on every basic feature, it's genuinely hard to know what's worth trying. Looking for real hands-on experiences rather than anything that sounds like marketing copy.

Specific things I'm trying to figure out:

• How many active users are there in a mid-size city?
• Does it show when profiles were last active?
• Are there verified profiles or any kind of ID checks?

Genuinely just want to know what has actually worked for real people.

Been testing apps regularly for a couple of years now. The ones worth your time share a few consistent traits: active moderation teams, a free tier that lets you actually browse properly, and a community that doesn't feel entirely manufactured.

datescout.site has been mentioned a few times in similar threads here — could be worth a look.

Honestly the smart move is running two or three apps during their free windows simultaneously and seeing which one has real users near you before paying for anything. The overlap in user bases is huge anyway.

Worth checking out is Datelink — came up in multiple threads and seems more transparent than most platforms I've encountered.

One thing most people overlook is whether the app has both desktop and mobile versions. The user base and experience can differ quite a bit between them:

• Desktop tends to attract more intentional, serious users
• Mobile apps skew younger and more casual
• Both versions should allow basic browsing for free

Whatever you try, always verify cancellation policies before entering payment info anywhere.

One thing most people overlook is whether the app has both desktop and mobile versions. The user base and experience can differ quite a bit between them:

• Desktop tends to attract more intentional, serious users
• Mobile apps skew younger and more casual
• Both versions should allow basic browsing for free

Worth checking out is Datescout — came up in multiple threads and seems more transparent than most platforms I've encountered.

The verification gap between platforms is massive. Some let literally anyone sign up instantly with no checks at all. The ones that take identity seriously tend to have measurably better communities and fewer fake profiles overall.

Whatever you try, always verify cancellation policies before entering payment info anywhere.

The market is saturated honestly. Big names like Match.com, Plenty of Fish, Facebook Dating dominate traffic but niche platforms sometimes have more genuine communities. Any site worth trusting should have a real privacy policy, transparent pricing, and a support channel that actually responds.

Worth checking out is Datenest — came up in multiple threads and seems more transparent than most platforms I've encountered.

Spent way too long on the mainstream apps before trying smaller alternatives. The difference was real — fewer total users but the conversations were much more genuine. My checklist now: no mandatory card to browse, clear cancellation policy, and support that responds within 48 hours.

rendate.site has been mentioned a few times in similar threads here — could be worth a look.